Candy or Cookie? You Be the Judge (Chocolate Chip Cookie Brittle)

Hello? Why didn’t someone tell me it was National Chocolate Chip Cookie Day…a couple of days ago? Yep, I missed it. Well, I almost missed it. As I was doing my late-night perusal of Instagram, what should pop up on my feed? A luscious-looking pic of chocolate chip cookies with the banner shouting out “Happy National Chocolate Chip Cookie Day!”.

WHAAT?

Damn it. If I had just gone to sleep instead of taking that last look at my feed. So there I was at midnight, guilted into making chocolate chip cookies. I envisioned myself staying up another couple of hours, baking off sheets of cookies one at a time (yes, I can’t bring myself to bake two sheets at once). UGH.

Then I remembered a recipe I had been wanting to try from Shauna Sever’s Midwest Made. Chocolate Chip Cookie Brittle. It starts with melted butter, yay, no waiting for butter to come to room temp. The batter can be made in one bowl with a wooden spoon (ok, and a whisk), the finished dough is then spread on a baking sheet and popped in the oven. ONE SHEET, that’s it.

I Am So Making Them

Surprisingly, the recipe calls for granulated sugar and no eggs. I double-checked the recipe, yep, no eggs, and no brown sugar. Hmmm, interesting, I apprehensively plowed on.  It also started with melted butter, yay, no creaming.

I gathered the dry ingredients as the butter cooled and got out my 12×17 sided cookie sheet (classic 1/2 sheet pan).  Added sugar to the cooled melted butter and beat until it formed a loose paste.  Poured in the flour and vanilla, stirred to combine and followed with the toasted nuts (don’t skip toasting, 5-6 minutes in a 350-degree oven) and chocolate.

Not Gonna Lie

The worse part was spreading the dough in the pan.  Don’t do what I did, which was plop all the dough in the center of the sheet pan.  Spread it out a little so it is easier to cover the pan.  You want the dough to be as even and thin as possible.  The dough will be approximately the same thickness as the chips.  I used Guittard’s Semi-Sweet Chocolate (ginormous) chips but almost any chip would work in this cookie, bittersweet, milk chocolate, or a combination.  Likewise, walnuts would work in place of pecans.

The cookie baked in 22 minutes.  Be extra vigilant towards the end as they brown pretty quickly.  The recipe does not have brown sugar and calls for only granulated sugar.  It’s important to bake it to nice toasty brown which results in a crisp, toffee flavored cookie.  It’s addictive.  Crunchy cookie base, oozy chocolate, and toasted nuts.  It straddles the line between cookie and candy, another winner from Shauna Sever.